In the wake of the November 2026 local government elections, fierce debate has erupted over coalition negotiations in Gauteng's hung metropolitan municipalities – particularly Johannesburg. 

According to political commentators and ActionSA leadership, the Democratic Alliance is facing intense accusations of hypocrisy for condemning potential coalition talks between ActionSA and the African National Congress (ANC), despite having entered into a national governing arrangement with the ANC after the 2024 general election.

The battle for Gauteng's metros

Following the municipal polls, coalition negotiations in Johannesburg, Tshwane, and Ekurhuleni have placed ActionSA in a pivotal kingmaker position. Reports that ActionSA and the ANC are nearing an agreement to co-govern these metros have drawn sharp criticism from the DA and its supporters, who have characterised a potential ActionSA-ANC partnership as regressive and a betrayal of opposition voters.

ActionSA leader Herman Mashaba has pushed back strongly against this framing, arguing that his party is being subjected to a double standard. In public statements, Mashaba asserted that while the DA labels its own engagement with the ANC as necessary political pragmatism, it portrays ActionSA's independent municipal negotiations as unprincipled. Mashaba and ActionSA chairperson Michael Beaumont have also stated that ActionSA's reluctance to partner with the DA in Johannesburg stems from specific leadership disputes, notably the DA's insistence on fielding Helen Zille as its mayoral candidate.

The Multi-Party Charter and the 2024 GNU

Critics of the DA point directly to the events surrounding the 2024 general election as the foundation for charges of inconsistency. Prior to the May 2024 vote, the DA spearheaded the formation of the Multi-Party Charter (MPC) – an opposition pact that included ActionSA, the Inkatha Freedom Party (IFP), the Freedom Front Plus (FF Plus), and several smaller parties – built explicitly on the premise of unseating the ANC and keeping it out of government.

However, when the 2024 election results left the ANC without an outright majority, the DA entered negotiations with the party and subsequently joined the Government of National Unity (GNU). ActionSA withdrew from the MPC in June 2024, citing a breach of the charter's foundational agreement not to partner with the ANC. Political analysts note that this history makes it difficult for the DA to claim the moral high ground when former charter partners explore similar arrangements at the local level.

The DA's perspective on coalitions

Conversely, the DA maintains that its approach to coalition governance is consistent and driven by constitutionalism and service delivery rather than rigid ideological exclusion. DA leaders, including Geordin Hill-Lewis, have advocated for a “Government of Local Unity” model in hung councils, arguing that broad-based stability is required to rescue failing municipal infrastructure.

From the DA's perspective, its participation in the national GNU – as well as its governing coalition with the IFP and ANC in KwaZulu-Natal – was a necessary measure to keep more radical parties, such as the Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) and the uMkhonto weSizwe (MK) Party, out of executive power. The DA contends that its objections in Gauteng are rooted in concerns that an ANC-ActionSA arrangement – potentially backed by the EFF or MK – would entrench existing municipal dysfunction rather than reform it. Furthermore, Hill-Lewis has maintained that the DA will not allow smaller parties to dictate its internal candidate selections, refusing to sacrifice Zille's nomination in Johannesburg.

Shifting alliances in South African politics

The friction between the DA and ActionSA highlights a broader reality in South African coalition politics: pre-election pacts frequently give way to post-election realpolitik. While the DA frames its national partnership with the ANC as a stabilising necessity, opponents view its condemnation of ActionSA's municipal talks as an effort to protect its own institutional power in Gauteng's economic heartland. As negotiations in Johannesburg come down to the wire, voters are left weighing competing claims of principle and pragmatism from parties that have found reasons to sit across the negotiating table from the ANC.